Legends of Equestria - Forum

General Category => The Retirement Home => Topic started by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jun 09, 13:09:07

Title: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jun 09, 13:09:07
Think of it as an alternate reality...

What if the internet never found out about Friendship is Magic and the fanbase never took off,

How do you think this would've effected the second season?
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Lary on 2012 Jun 09, 13:12:18
Spoiler: show
The world would be a better place.

[spoiler]Seriously.
[/spoiler]
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: GalvinRoe on 2012 Jun 09, 13:13:27
The world would be a little duller.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Night Pony on 2012 Jun 09, 13:15:54
MLP:FIM doesn't air at my county so I won't know about it.My life will continue as normal,usually obsessing over other things like games or animes.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Xeno Aura on 2012 Jun 09, 13:27:56
Well LoE wouldn't exist for a start. :D

EDIT: MLP airs here in the UK, but you have to pay to get the channel it airs on I believe.

I only heard about MLP via various references to it and YouTube videos on the internet.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Zygrograxgra on 2012 Jun 09, 13:36:52
Eh...
Sites like EQD wouldn't exist (Something I find would be good. Thinking about that site makes me rather mad.)
However, some of the best works of art I've seen wouldn't exist.
It's a so-so thing I guess.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Itty Bit on 2012 Jun 09, 17:05:46
Well, it would have its ups ad downs.
Personally, I'd still love the cartoon. Heck, I got into the show before I knew there even was a brony community.
However, I'd probably still be a major internet lurker, never really making any friends online like I have been now. I'd probably still be a big ol' doormat too, like I used to be before I met you guys.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Ozzy on 2012 Jun 09, 17:50:20
Having not watched season 2, I don't know it would effect the show itself, however on a personal level, I think my life would be pretty similar as it is now, only my leisure time would be replaced with somthing else, the big part of this fandom that would be vastly different would be the people I have met over the internet in recent times

I'd also imagine my sleeping/emotional state/education would be atleast somewhat less derailed than what it is now
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Crystal Chaos on 2012 Jun 09, 18:10:33
I would be even more lonely with nothing to hold onto in life.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: GalvinRoe on 2012 Jun 09, 18:11:56
I certainly would NOT have a whole bunch of new pony songs  lol!
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: lurk852 on 2012 Jun 09, 18:46:56
Quote from: Itty Bit on 2012 Jun 09, 17:05:46
Personally, I'd still love the cartoon.


Perhaps not for long... I don't know all the relevant statistics, but I'd guess that without the bronies, the show would be much less commercially successful, and thus less likely to continue for a long time.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: The Wandering Magus on 2012 Jun 09, 19:23:18
I'd watch it like I watch shoujo anime.  I have an obsession over stuff like that anyways, Shugo Chara being my most recent one.

But probably wouldn't have many friends, stuck doing nothing in particular, some art on the side, roleplaying on thefantasyforum.com and stuff like that.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Mr.Darkling on 2012 Jun 09, 19:39:20
Quote from: Lary on 2012 Jun 09, 13:12:18
Spoiler: show
The world would be a better place.



MY world, would likely be much more duller.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: The Wandering Magus on 2012 Jun 09, 19:54:00
probably wouldn't have pulled out of depression as fast.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Xeno Aura on 2012 Jun 09, 19:56:41
Yup, MLP certainly cheers me up, and I wouldn't have ever watched it if there hadn't been a ton of random MLP stuff on the net nagging me to watch it. :)
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Lary on 2012 Jun 09, 20:19:04
Quote from: lurk852 on 2012 Jun 09, 18:46:56

Perhaps not for long... I don't know all the relevant statistics, but I'd guess that without the bronies, the show would be much less commercially successful, and thus less likely to continue for a long time.


Better to die strong than to live in vain.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Azure Dusk on 2012 Jun 09, 20:28:19
I wouldn't be nearly as happy.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Crystal Chaos on 2012 Jun 09, 21:07:52
Might have actually committed suicide...  :'(
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Soft Fang on 2012 Jun 09, 21:19:30
Wouldn't have changed a thing with me. I still would love the show and watch it.

Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Ozzy on 2012 Jun 10, 04:15:56
Quote from: Lary on 2012 Jun 09, 13:12:18
Spoiler: show
The world would be a better place.

[spoiler]Seriously.
[/spoiler]


So..you think our community is bad...yet you have the most time online here..seems legit
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Cutiebone on 2012 Jun 10, 15:11:03
Quote from: Itty Bit on 2012 Jun 09, 17:05:46
Well, it would have its ups ad downs.
Personally, I'd still love the cartoon. Heck, I got into the show before I knew there even was a brony community.
However, I'd probably still be a major internet lurker, never really making any friends online like I have been now. I'd probably still be a big ol' doormat too, like I used to be before I met you guys.

Same :)
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Phoenix dust on 2012 Jun 11, 04:41:02
Given the fact its an alternative reality.
I can only speculate and assume the earths core gave out, causing the solar system to collapse,
sparking a chain reaction of, coincidently this would end the universe before recreating the big bang,
creating another reality upon where Friendship is magic does exist.

And the event would continue to happen until such a time arises and brings forth the wonder and magic we all share here today.  :]

Dust.   
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Dawnstar on 2012 Jun 11, 08:39:14
I probably would have never watched the show personally. The large amount of fan art that showed up on deviant art made me wonder why it was so popular and I understood after watching a few episodes.

The show would also have less of an influence from the fans (less hidden jokes and references only older fans would get, fan-favorite background ponies would probably not be the same, etc) and the show would probably have a lot less potential and shorter lifespan than it does due to the extra fan base.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jun 11, 09:51:24
Quote from: Phoenix dust on 2012 Jun 11, 04:41:02
Given the fact its an alternative reality.
I can only speculate and assume the earths core gave out, causing the solar system to collapse,
sparking a chain reaction of, coincidently this would end the universe before recreating the big bang,
creating another reality upon where Friendship is magic does exist.

And the would continue to happen until such a time arises and brings forth the wonder and magic we all share here today.  :]

Dust.   

Egads....it all makes sense now  :I
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Fudgemuffin on 2012 Jun 11, 11:21:11
I wouldn't of never met a amazing friend. I'd still be a quiet person since discovering ponies has made me come out of my shell and never shut up. My depression wouldn't have lifted a bit.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: The Wandering Magus on 2012 Jun 11, 11:22:38
Quote from: Phoenix dust on 2012 Jun 11, 04:41:02
Given the fact its an alternative reality.
I can only speculate and assume the earths core gave out, causing the solar system to collapse,
sparking a chain reaction of, coincidently this would end the universe before recreating the big bang,
creating another reality upon where Friendship is magic does exist.

And the event would continue to happen until such a time arises and brings forth the wonder and magic we all share here today.  :]

Dust.   
I like how you put your name at the end, it's so appropriate to the image you conjured ovO
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Dreadnaught 308 on 2012 Jun 11, 12:27:25
if bronies didnt exist...PARADOX O:
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jun 12, 08:19:29
I was really hoping to get some answers on how season 2 would've been like and if derpy hooves was never put in because nobody pointed her out in the first episode.  >:/
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Doomguy on 2012 Jun 12, 09:14:13
If the fanbase never existed, I probably wouldn't have spent so much time on the internet enjoying pony stuff. Although I may have decided to run into it later on since I love Lauren Faust's work. :D
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Lorelai on 2012 Jun 12, 09:57:50
Quote from: Dawnstar on 2012 Jun 11, 08:39:14
I probably would have never watched the show personally. The large amount of fan art that showed up on deviant art made me wonder why it was so popular and I understood after watching a few episodes.

This, except it wasn't just the art, it was the fan videos, songs, images, ect that I kept seeing everywhere that encouraged me to go see what the hype was all about.

If I did somehow get into the show though, I'd probably explode from having nobody to talk with about it.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: videogamehunter on 2012 Jun 23, 14:27:57
I guess I wouldn't be into Mlp. It because of the internet I discover it. I probably just keep collecting video games and.watch anime all day.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Iron Girella on 2012 Jun 24, 11:45:20
I think that everything would be a little bit sad ç_ç mlp it's just an epic series, and it's even more awesome that there is a community like this one behind it, that makes it even more magical! I think that without mlp i would have been more focussed on thinks like Dota, or maybe some mroe anime, i dunno, but i'm very very happy to had found this world  ;)
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Firefly on 2012 Jun 28, 21:15:39
I would have been obssessing with transformice rather than mlp fim XD
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: LarryMcLie on 2012 Jun 29, 11:47:21
This question would never be asked.
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: The Wandering Magus on 2012 Jun 29, 15:59:04
Quote from: LarryMcLie on 2012 Jun 29, 11:47:21
This question would never be asked.
oh the meta~! ovO
Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jun 29, 16:12:12
Quote from: LarryMcLie on 2012 Jun 29, 11:47:21
This question would never be asked.

Title: Re: What if the Brony fan base never existed?
Post by: Book Smarts on 2012 Jul 01, 13:58:33
This was way off what I wanted to discuss about
*locks thread*