Bronies and G1 MLP

Started by Applestack, 2013 Aug 28, 10:17:06

previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Do the majority of bronies hate the 1st generation of My Little Pony?

Yes
14 (36.8%)
No, only the minority do
24 (63.2%)

Total Members Voted: 38

Go Down

Applestack

No trash talk or complaining, I only want answers (via votes).
"Lights of hope that keep the world turning are carved in the heart, staring at the sky spreading yonder."

Chishio Kunrin

It's mainly G3 and G3.5 that bronies have a problem with. At least G1 had some actual story-telling going on.

"(Ticktock, time is running out) What are you doing now?
I don't know where you are, don't even know your name.
They think I'm crazy, my heartbeat goes up..."

GoldenTerrabyte

I don't really know the diff between G1 G2 and G3.
I'm back

phirenor

2013 Aug 28, 13:45:07 #3 Last Edit: 2013 Aug 28, 13:47:54 by phirenor
Actually, g3 isn't that bad. And g1 is kinda normal.
But G3.5 Scootaloo... I see her face in the nightmares!  :]

GoldenTerrabyte

Scootaloo existed prior to FIM?
I'm back

Night Pony


I want to thank all of the artist that have drawn my OCs.
Night Shine and Moon Violet

GoldenTerrabyte

Quote from: Night Pony on 2013 Aug 28, 13:48:11

O: What the...? How...? How scary did the others look if they existed? I wanna see the disgusting Twilight Sparkle!
I'm back

phirenor

Quote from: Yellowpikmin476 on 2013 Aug 28, 13:51:19
Quote from: Night Pony on 2013 Aug 28, 13:48:11

O: What the...? How...? How scary did the others look if they existed? I wanna see the disgusting Twilight Sparkle!

That's too creepy.
Even early Twilight G4 version is creepy.

Night Pony

2013 Aug 28, 14:18:32 #8 Last Edit: 2013 Aug 28, 14:20:28 by Night Pony
Actually previous Twilight is current Twilight's mom.

Post Merge

Spoiler: show

I want to thank all of the artist that have drawn my OCs.
Night Shine and Moon Violet

GoldenTerrabyte

Quote from: Night Pony on 2013 Aug 28, 14:18:32
Actually previous Twilight is current Twilight's mom.

Post Merge

Spoiler: show

Faust's original art is SO CUTE! But the others... really kinda ugly. And red Applejack? And earth pony Fluttershy?
I'm back

Night Pony

Quote from: Yellowpikmin476 on 2013 Aug 28, 14:31:07
Quote from: Night Pony on 2013 Aug 28, 14:18:32
Actually previous Twilight is current Twilight's mom.

Post Merge

Spoiler: show

Faust's original art is SO CUTE! But the others... really kinda ugly. And red Applejack? And earth pony Fluttershy?


Toys aren't know for being accurate. They took the wings from Pinkie Pie and gave them to Fluttershy to keep the balance.

I want to thank all of the artist that have drawn my OCs.
Night Shine and Moon Violet

GoldenTerrabyte

Yeah. I like the white Pinkie (a.k.a. Surprise) so much! TOO CUUUUTE!
I'm back

Chishio Kunrin

The main problem with G3 and G3.5 was that the stories had no conflict whatsoever. It was really, really boring.

In fact, theBaglady74 (now known on Youtube under the account Non-Brony Commentaries) did a commentary video where he watched two G3 episodes. He summarized one of them pretty perfectly:
Quote"I can't find my shoes."
"Did you look in the closet?"
"No."
"They're not here. Did you look under the bed?"
"No."
"Here they are."
THE END.

That's basically what most people think we're watching. "Teehee, let's have a tea party." "Ok." The end.
"Our band sounds terrible." "Hey, let's try actually playing together." "Oh yeah." The end, solved in way less than 11 minutes. I'm serious.

"(Ticktock, time is running out) What are you doing now?
I don't know where you are, don't even know your name.
They think I'm crazy, my heartbeat goes up..."

GoldenTerrabyte

IKR? That's why I love FIM. It's not like that.
I'm back

Nala Valor

I LOVED G1 <3 I got in contact with the show because of pony figurines that I really enjoyed combing and petting and playing with the others who were majorly girls >.>
(Was the only guy playing. Please don't ask why)

Minor-T5

The older generations of MLP are just, meh. I have tried watching some of the older ones, but I couldn't take it, I had to turn it off...
The ponies I will play as:
Schmooky Luke, Barney Calhoof, and Floofie Pillow
---------------
Steam: Schmookyluke
Skype: schmooky_luke

GoldenTerrabyte

Quote from: Nala Valor on 2013 Aug 28, 23:42:00
I LOVED G1 <3 I got in contact with the show because of pony figurines that I really enjoyed combing and petting and playing with the others who were majorly girls >.>
(Was the only guy playing. Please don't ask why)
Hey, I've played with BARBIES! With my SISTERS!
I'm back

phirenor


This is the only way you can watch previous generations to the very end. This is easier, when somepony suffers with you, watching this piece of *Squeak*. lol

GoldenTerrabyte

I tried... THEY'RE JUST TOO UGLY!!!
I'm back

Applestack

Actually, that Baby Scootaloo design existed after G3.5.
"Lights of hope that keep the world turning are carved in the heart, staring at the sky spreading yonder."

Go Up